From David Sirota’s The Lever

  • perestroika
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    8
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    Cars aren’t going anywhere. Achieveing a 20% reduction would be great, but people in developing countries are only now getting started with cars. The only choice: what kind of cars?

    Public transport is good, the nearest city to where I live has free public transport (Tallinn, capital of Estonia) but people still use cars. Public transport cannot get everywhere.

    I propose a few test cases: try transporting someone old and frail, or a sick child or pet. Go by public transport, walk 10 minutes to the stop, switch lines, wait, walk 5 minutes to the hospital / clinic. If the old person tires, you can’t carry them. Now try the same route with 20 cm of snow on ground. Now try with ice on ground. Now try in a storm. If you have a car, you’ll be starting it up (if you don’t, you’ll be asking a friend or hiring a cab).

    The question will be “which type of car”, “whose car” and “how often”.

    Also, there will always be people working in the other end of the city, or in the countryside (where cars are practically required since public transport may be miles and hours away). People often have to decide whether to move near their job or move near their relatives (moving is an big hassle, it is not always possible to sell / buy / rent when needed, property prices differ, moving into a rich neighbourhood may be unrealistic) or commute. Smarter planning may reduce the flow, but there will be a flow. And industries are hard to integrate into living districts.

    • bdiddy@lemmy.one
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      arrow-down
      25
      ·
      11 months ago

      developing countries are absolutely choosing EVs and actually 2 wheeled EVs because they are cheap, reliable, and take up less space. So this idea that they’ll be all ICE cars is not right in the least. In fact China and India both of which are developing countires are adopting these in droves. The data is there.

      The snowball has started and very quickly oil demand will be in terminal decline. Doesn’t do anything to the short term problem, but does help with the very long term problem.

      For now we need to figure out how to get carbon out of the atmosphere that’s where governments need to step in and find scientific solutions to this problem while we transition. But… The GOP is everywhere unfortunately